Black, milky, filtered, decaf, first thing in the morning or never after lunch? Coffee can comfortably be part of a healthy diet, but how you drink it matters more than you might think.
Coffee occupies a strange place in the world of nutrition. One week it appears to be practically a health food; the next, someone is telling you that your morning cup is destroying your sleep, raising your cortisol or should never be consumed before breakfast.
The reality is considerably less dramatic.
Large reviews of the research have generally found that moderate coffee consumption is associated with favourable health outcomes rather than harm. But much of this evidence is observational, which means it cannot prove that coffee itself is responsible for those benefits.
There is also an important difference between drinking a couple of coffees and consuming caffeine throughout the day. Likewise, a simple filter coffee and a large drink filled with syrup, cream and sugar may both be called “coffee”, but nutritionally they are very different.
So, if you enjoy coffee, what is the healthiest way to drink it?
Is coffee actually good for you?
There is surprisingly reassuring evidence around coffee.
A major umbrella review published in The BMJ, which examined more than 200 meta-analyses of observational research, found that coffee consumption was more often associated with health benefits than harm. Moderate consumption was associated with lower rates of several outcomes, including cardiovascular disease, type 2 diabetes and some liver conditions.
For several outcomes, the strongest associations appeared at around three to four cups per day.
That does not mean everyone should start drinking four coffees a day.
People who drink coffee may differ from non-coffee drinkers in other ways, and observational studies cannot establish cause and effect. The sensible interpretation is that moderate coffee consumption appears generally compatible with good health for most people—not that coffee is medicine.
How much coffee is too much?
It is more useful to think about caffeine than cups.
A tiny espresso and a large filter coffee aren’t equivalent, and caffeine content can vary substantially depending on the beans, serving size and brewing method.
The European Food Safety Authority says caffeine intakes of up to 400mg per day from all sources generally do not raise safety concerns for healthy adults, excluding pregnancy.
But 400mg is a safety threshold, not a target.
Some people can drink several coffees and feel perfectly normal. Others experience anxiety, trembling, a racing heart or difficulty sleeping after considerably less.
Your individual response matters.
And remember that coffee isn’t your only possible source. Tea, energy drinks, cola, chocolate, supplements and some medicines can also contain caffeine.
The healthiest coffee may be filtered
How you make coffee can affect more than flavour.
Coffee naturally contains compounds called cafestol and kahweol. These diterpenes can increase blood cholesterol, particularly LDL cholesterol.
Paper filters retain much of these compounds. Unfiltered brewing methods allow considerably more of them into the finished drink.
That means paper-filtered coffee has an advantage if you drink a lot of coffee or are particularly concerned about cholesterol.
French press, Scandinavian boiled coffee and Turkish-style coffee tend to contain more of these cholesterol-raising compounds. Espresso can also contain them, although serving sizes are much smaller.
This doesn’t mean an occasional French press is dangerous. But if you drink several large coffees every day, switching at least some of them to paper-filtered coffee is a simple choice worth considering.
Interestingly, recent research examining workplace coffee machines has also found that some machine-made coffees can contain substantially more diterpenes than traditional paper-filtered coffee, although concentrations vary considerably between machines.
So the humble paper filter still has something going for it.
Is black coffee healthier than coffee with milk?
Black coffee is extremely low in calories and contains no added sugar, which makes it the simplest option.
But that doesn’t mean adding milk suddenly makes coffee unhealthy.
A modest amount of dairy milk or an unsweetened plant-based alternative is unlikely to transform an otherwise balanced diet. Milk also provides nutrients of its own, including protein and, depending on the type, calcium and other micronutrients.
Where coffee can change dramatically is when it becomes closer to dessert.
Large flavoured coffees can contain generous amounts of syrup, sugar, cream and toppings. If you drink them occasionally because you enjoy them, that is one thing. If several arrive every day, you’re no longer simply discussing the health effects of coffee.
For everyday drinking, coffee with a little milk is perfectly reasonable.
Sugar matters more than whether your coffee is black
There is a tendency to treat black coffee as virtuous and anything added to it as a nutritional failure.
That is unnecessary.
If you enjoy one teaspoon of sugar in your morning coffee, the overall quality of your diet matters considerably more than that single teaspoon.
The issue is accumulation.
Sugar in the first coffee. A flavoured syrup in the second. A sweetened iced coffee during the afternoon. Suddenly something that began as a virtually calorie-free drink is contributing a significant amount of added sugar.
You don’t need to force yourself to drink bitter coffee you dislike. But if your regular order contains several pumps of syrup, reducing the sweetness gradually may be one of the easiest ways to make it an everyday rather than occasional drink.
When should you stop drinking coffee?
This may matter more than whether you add a splash of milk.
Caffeine can interfere with sleep, and sensitivity varies substantially between people. EFSA notes that even a single 100mg dose may affect sleep duration and patterns in some adults, particularly when consumed close to bedtime.
The important point is that caffeine doesn’t necessarily stop affecting you when you stop feeling stimulated.
Someone can drink an afternoon coffee, fall asleep that evening and still experience changes in sleep quality or duration.
Rather than following a universal rule such as “never drink coffee after 2pm”, work backwards from your bedtime and pay attention to your response. If you regularly struggle to fall asleep, wake during the night or don’t feel rested in the morning, moving your final caffeinated coffee earlier is an easy experiment.
A coffee that gives you a small afternoon boost but compromises your night’s sleep is a questionable trade.
Do you need to wait before drinking coffee in the morning?
Probably not.
One of the more persistent wellness claims is that you should wait 60 or 90 minutes after waking before drinking coffee because cortisol is naturally high in the morning.
There isn’t strong evidence that healthy adults need to obey a precise caffeine waiting period.
If you enjoy coffee shortly after waking and it doesn’t cause problems, there is little reason to feel you are drinking it incorrectly.
There may, however, be practical reasons to delay it. If drinking coffee immediately means you consume more caffeine throughout the day, waiting might help. And if you are particularly sensitive to caffeine, experimenting with timing is reasonable.
But the idea that everyone needs to wait exactly 90 minutes shouldn’t be treated as established nutritional science.
Is coffee on an empty stomach bad for you?
Another popular rule says coffee should never be consumed before food.
Again, that is too broad.
There isn’t good evidence that drinking coffee on an empty stomach is inherently harmful for healthy people.
However, coffee can cause digestive discomfort in some individuals. If drinking it before breakfast gives you heartburn, nausea or stomach irritation, having it with food—or reducing the amount—may make you feel better.
That is an individual response, not evidence that everyone needs to eat before their first espresso.
You don’t need to manufacture a breakfast you don’t want purely to “protect” yourself from coffee.
What about decaf?
Decaffeinated coffee is an underrated option.
It still contains many of the compounds found in ordinary coffee but with most of the caffeine removed. Research has also found favourable associations between decaffeinated coffee consumption and some health outcomes, including type 2 diabetes, although, as with regular coffee, much of this evidence is observational.
For someone who loves the taste and ritual of coffee but is sensitive to caffeine, decaf can be particularly useful.
It also solves a simple problem: sometimes you want another coffee without wanting another dose of caffeine.
Switching to decaf later in the day can allow you to keep the ritual without making sleep more difficult.
Who should be more careful with caffeine?
The 400mg figure doesn’t apply universally.
EFSA advises that pregnant women keep total caffeine intake from all sources to no more than 200mg per day.
People who experience anxiety, palpitations, sleep problems or certain medical conditions may also find that considerably lower amounts suit them better. Some medications can interact with caffeine or alter how quickly the body processes it.
If coffee reliably makes you feel worse, the fact that population-level research generally finds it safe isn’t a reason to keep drinking the same amount.
Personal tolerance counts.
So, what is the healthiest way to drink coffee?
For most healthy adults, the answer is refreshingly ordinary.
Drink an amount of coffee that doesn’t leave you jittery or interfere with your sleep. If you drink several cups every day, paper-filtered coffee is a sensible choice, particularly if cholesterol is a concern. Adding some milk is perfectly reasonable, while large amounts of added sugar and syrup are better treated as an occasional pleasure than an essential part of every cup.
Consider decaf when you want coffee later in the day. And don’t worry about internet rules telling you that coffee must be consumed at an exact number of minutes after waking.
Most importantly, don’t turn a perfectly enjoyable habit into another nutritional optimisation project.
The healthiest coffee isn’t necessarily black, organic, consumed at 10.17am or accompanied by an elaborate morning ritual.
For most people, it is simply coffee you enjoy, in a moderate amount, prepared in a way that suits your health and consumed early enough that you can still sleep well that night.
Further Reading
Why Your Life Feels Faster as You Get Older
Stay Connected
Subscribe to the Together Magazine newsletter for thoughtful features, personal development insights, cultural recommendations, museum exhibitions, events in Brussels and Belgium, and the latest stories delivered directly to your inbox.
